Translate

Showing posts with label UNCRPD. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UNCRPD. Show all posts

Tuesday, 18 February 2014

Time To Enable The Disabled


Time To Enable The Disabled

A Bill as politically non-contentious as the Rights of the Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014, on which the aspirations of millions of people with disabilities are riding, is, shocking though this may sound, stuck between a rock and a hard place. On the one hand, it was recently introduced in the Rajya Sabha but disruptions over political issues like Telangana have ensured that the Bill, which seeks to increase the reservation quota for the disabled in public sector jobs and seats in higher educational institutions, was not taken up for discussion.

On the other hand, the disability rights activists seem to be divided over the proposed amendments as it is alleged that their recommendations have been ignored and it is a watered down version of their earlier demands. Moreover, it was a leaked copy of the Bill that made activists realise that the Bill to be tabled in the Rajya Sabha was not the same as the one available on the website of the ministry of social justice and empowerment, leading to protest rallies in Delhi. While the Bill, rightly, seeks to raise the number of disabilities from seven to 19, it includes only those who suffer not less than 40% of the relevant disability — this many activists feel is quite ambiguous especially in cases of intellectual disabilities and it does not ensure full legal capacity to people with disabilities.

In a country where of 70 million people with disabilities, only about 100,000 have succeeded in obtaining employment in industry, and inaccessible public infrastructure is a cause of their daily travails, this was a controversy the government could have done without had the authorities concerned kept all the stakeholders in the loop. However, practicality suggests that parliamentarians, cutting across the party lines, must now rise above politics and ensure that the Bill sees the light of day.

The Bill may be far from being perfect but given the fact that the ongoing Parliament session is the last one before the general elections, there’s no time to lose. There are several social and infrastructural barriers that need to be crossed to make the Bill effective on the ground. Instead of taking a one-step-forward-and-two-steps-back approach, the government must show urgency to build on what already exists.

Source: http://www.hindustantimes.com/comment/time-to-enable-the-disabled/article1-1184681.aspx#sthash.qtDDaNvi.dpuf

A Hurried Disabilities Bill Will Serve No Purpose


A Hurried Disabilities Bill Will Serve No Purpose



Let us not hurriedly enact a retrograde legislation for all disabilities, which would be impossible to amend for the next 25 years. In order to correct the injustice of exclusion, let us not create an equality of oppression.

The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill was introduced in the Rajya Sabha to universal criticism and till now, 16 amendments have been circulated to members of the upper House in an effort to save the Bill. The objective of the legislation was stated as "a Bill to give effect to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities" (UN CRPD). Hence it must be in consonance with the requirements of the Convention to fulfill its primary purpose. The CRPD mandates an absolute prohibition on discrimination on grounds of disability, but this Bill permits discrimination provided it is to achieve any legitimate aim, in clear violation of the CRPD!

The CRPD prohibits deprivation of liberty on grounds of disability. The Bill cleverly inserts one word to change the guarantee altogether: it says that no person shall be deprived of his or her personal liberty only on grounds of disability. This formulation was rejected while drafting the CRPD since it permits the deprivation of liberty when a person with disability is destitute or considered to be 'dangerous'. For thousands, the addition of 'only' could mean being forced to live in institutions for the rest of their lives.

The other core CRPD principle that remains to be examined is the right to exercise legal capacity on an equal basis with others in all aspects of life. Presently scores of laws disqualify persons with disabilities from marrying, inheriting, voting, etc. The CRPD seeks to offset disqualifications imposed upon people with intellectual, psychosocial and developmental disabilities by recognising their right to live their lives according to their will and preference.


However, the 2014 Bill did not even mention the right to legal capacity. In the amendment, legal capacity has been recognised as an obligation of the government, not a right of persons with disabilities. If the government fails to ensure legal capacity, then the person with disabilities can do nothing but bemoan the poor implementation of Indian laws. Consequently, entitlement of reservations in jobs becomes meaningless for persons with disabilities. If it were possible to make things worse, section 110 of the legislation states categorically that the Bill will not override any existing laws, which means all discriminatory laws will continue to be valid!


However, despite the many flaws in the Bill, people with the newly-included disabilities are pressing for its enactment because these disabilities have been waiting for inclusion in the Act since 1999 and feel they cannot wait any more. This grievance is undeniably genuine. The correct way to address this concern would be to amend the Act of 1995, whether by Act or ordinance to include the long-excluded disabilities.


Let us not hurriedly enact a retrograde legislation for all disabilities, which would be impossible to amend for the next 25 years. In order to correct the injustice of exclusion, let us not create an equality of oppression.


Source: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/hyderabad/A-hurried-disabilities-Bill-will-serve-no-purpose/articleshow/30579944.cms

Monday, 10 February 2014

Protest against Passing of “The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014” in Current Form


Protest against Passing of “The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014” in Current Form



As it is well known that the Government of India had tabled an older version of The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014 in the Rajya Sabha on Friday. In spite of lots of pressure from across the country wide disability rights activist, DPO’s, NGO’s as well as disability matters expert, Government willing to pass the bill in the current form, under a conspiracy and pre plan, which is in against off the Disabled community. 


Mr. Madhba Bisoyi, Assistant Regional Director, IGNOU and Chief Advisor of Milton Charitable Foundation for the Visually Handicapped told that the definition of the blindness at Sl. No. 2 of the schedule to the Bill is not clear and further will create more confusion with the regard to certification of blindness and low vision. Section 33 (2) is also reducing the rights of the differently - abled by mentioning that the employer is allowed to appoint a person without disability after one year, if the vacancy could not be filled by a person with disability, which was earlier not allowed. 


On the other hand Mr. Harsh Chandra Rath, president of the Milton Charitable Foundation for the Visually Handicapped blamed that in the name of empowering the differently - abled, the Government is planning to snatch their rights. He said in the existing PWD Act 1995, there is provision of age relaxation of 10 years, which has been reduced in the current bill by just 5 years for groups C & D. It will have a negative impact not only to the 2.68 crore population of differently - abled but also to the future generation. This provision will affect their social as well as financial empowerment.


Mr. Rajnish Kumar Arya, Assistant Professor mentioned that the current draft also violet the United Nation Charter of Rights Persons with Disabilities. Being a signatory it is India’s obligation to compile a bill according to it. He referred some of the most important provision of the UNCRPD as – the adoption of the social model of definition of disability in Article 1, the right to accessibility under Article 9, the right to fill legal capacity under Article 12, the right of independent living under Article 19, the right to inclusive education under Article 24, and the most important right, right to participation in political and public life under Article 29, have all been either diluted or outright ignored in this Bill.


Mr. Arya expressed his protest against the provision of education for persons with disabilities in the current bill. He told that as per Article 24 of UNCRPD the children with disabilities have the right to access an inclusive, quality and free primary education as well as secondary education.  He mentioned that Section 30 of the proposed Bill actually creates a non-obstante clause, which excludes the application of the RTE 2009 Act to Children with ‘benchmark disabilities’ i.e. more than 40% if a ‘Specified disability’. The second part of the clause states that every child with benchmark disabilities has a right to education in a neighborhood school, or in a special school, “if necessary”. There is no clarity as to who is to determine the necessity.


Mr. Ranjan Kumar Biswal, General Secretary of the Foundation for the Visually Handicapped, expressed his protest against the manner of the Government. He told that the draft Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill was shrouded in mystery since its notification on the website of the Ministry of Social Justice and Welfare in 2012. For a Bill that was touted to be framed by an inclusive process, the version of the Bill cleared by the Cabinet was only made available to the public just a fortnight before the proposed parliamentary session which seeks its introduction and passing. 


Mr. Biswal also mentioned that Section 10 of the proposed Bill deal with “accessibility in voting” and states that the Election Commission of India and State Election Commission shall ensure that all polling station are accessible to persons with disabilities and that all materials related to the electoral process are easily understandable by and accessible to them. This is severely limiting the scope of Article 29 of UNCRPD, which recognise the right and opportunity to stand for elections.


Wednesday, 5 February 2014

The New and Secretive Draft Actually Reduces the Rights and Powers of Indians with Disabilities


No Piecemeal Change Can Fix Our Terrible Disability Bill
The new and secretive draft actually reduces the rights and powers of Indians with disabilities.

By Amba Salelkar


In December 2013, protests erupted all over the country to demand the speedy passage of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill (RPD Bill), which had just received the approval of the Cabinet. Senior disability rights activists led protest rallies and held meetings with politicians in the ruling UPA government as well as in the Opposition parties who all rallied behind the Bill - one whose contents were known to absolutely no one outside the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and the Cabinet.


In good faith, everyone believed that the Bill would not have changed substantially from its 2012 version - available on the ministry's website - which was drafted following detailed consultations with persons with disabilities and organizations working with them.


Simultaneously, attempts were made to find out the contents of the Bill after press reports relayed the assurances of a 'guaranteed no questions asked' passage of the Bill. Discomfort began setting in when these attempts were met with hostile responses, and access to its contents was also barred under the Right to Information Act. The disabilities movement was shocked when the Bill was eventually leaked to find that it was not even close to the draft that the same ministry had proposed just 15 months ago.


It is impossible to understand the problems with the Bill without delving slightly into its history, and the history of the disability rights struggle in general. India has a huge population of persons with disabilities, possibly greater than the World Health Organization estimate that 15 percent of any nation's population is disabled.


Two-thirds of the world's blind are estimated to live in India, and conditions such as polio and malnutrition in both mothers and infants have also been linked to the causes for many disabilities in India.

Even so, there was no legislation on disability rights till 1995, and for a long time, psychosocial and intellectual disabilities were the only ones which fell under the purview of any laws  in India. This has a long history, beginning with the Lunacy (Supreme Courts Act) of 1858, under which there were the first targets of institutionalization - a practice unheard of in India until the British era.


The Indian Lunacy Act of 1912 defined "lunatics" as "idiots or persons of unsound mind", and prevailed as the sole statute on persons with disabilities for nearly 80 years. For persons with disabilities in the throes of poverty, the legal system mostly treated them as criminals. Persons with disabilities caused by leprosy or those who were forced to beg for a living found themselves incarcerated in Beggars' Homes for indefinite periods of time under anti-beggary statutes.


Not that disability rights were recognized world over. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, in 1948, did not recognize disability rights despite the fact that the first victims of the Nazi death camps were in fact children with disabilities in accordance with "Action T4". In fact, it was only in 2001 that the United Nations actually began discussions on drafting a convention on the rights of persons with disabilities, though many smaller international covenants had strengthened disability rights along the way.


The Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995, based on the "Proclamation on the Full Participation and Equality of People with Disabilities in the Asian and Pacific Region", marked a cornerstone for the disability rights movement in India. The initial enthusiasm soon gave way to frustration, however, when the best provisions of the Act were thwarted in practice.


Reservations in the government sector were being obstructed by various conflicting office memoranda, and would only be resolved by the Supreme Court nearly 18 years later. There were no provisions enforcing accessibility requirements in public places. And women with disabilities, a slowly emerging force, began voicing the fact that they weren't being mentioned at all.


India had moved on to attempting to set standards at the international level, and was one of the 27 countries in the working group to draft the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. India ratified the UNCRPD without reservations.


This was despite the fact that according to the National Centre for Promotion of Employment of Disabled People (which maintains the UNCRPD India website) there were two areas in which India's attempts remained unsuccessful - one was in involving parents associations, and the second was in having a special focus group on persons with multiple and severe disabilities.


Though evidently not popular world over, this approach was extremely rooted in domestic law. In 1999, efforts by various NGOs and parents' organizations led to the formation of the National Trust, governed by its own Act. The Trust manages a Rs 100-crore grant from the central government and uses the interest from it for activities related to the four disabilities it deals with - autism, mental retardation, cerebral palsy and multiple disabilities.

By then, the mental health care regime had also changed in India, and the 1987 Mental Health Act limited the definition of "mentally ill" to "a person who is in need of treatment by reason of any mental disorder other than mental retardation." The "mentally ill" were also recognized as persons with disabilities under the 1995 Act.


The one thing the "mentally ill" and persons under the National Trust Act do share, however, is the requirement of a legal guardian. Under the 1987 Act, the person must be shown to be incapable of taking care of himself and of managing his property in order for a guardian to be appointed. According to the National Trust Act, the law presumes a person under the Act requires a guardian unless a local-level committee finds otherwise.

These fetters on the exercise of "legal capacity" have had a myriad consequences, one of which is a circular issued by the Reserve Bank of India allowing persons falling under these laws to only have bank accounts opened and operated by certified guardians.

Two years later, the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment constituted a committee for the drafting of a new CRPD-compliant Disabilities Bill. This committee was chaired by Dr Sudha Kaul, and included members with various disabilities and from different organizations. Two members resigned on the grounds that the right to full legal capacity of all persons with disabilities was not being seriously considered by the committee, which was also comprised of parents' organizations that voiced reservations about the recognition of this right.


The committee submitted its draft compiled by the Center for Disability Studies, NALSAR University of Law, Hyderabad, in June 2011. The Ministry responded in September 2012 with the revised draft legislation. Although many groups expressed their views against some provisions, the Ministry did not officially invite comments, and the draft was circulated - among states in April 2013, and among other Ministries in August 2013 - before being finalized in its current form.


The RPD Bill violates everything within the UNCRPD and without. Persons with disabilities covered under the Mental Health Act and the National Trusts Act, have, in a way, been let off easily, because the Bill doesn't change their already marginalized position much, if at all.


The 1995 Act was silent on many rights, so one could still argue that those rights existed somewhere in expansive interpretations of Article 21 of the Constitution of India, perhaps. And many of these rights have been achieved through case law before. The Bill, however, threatens to negate all of the achievements of judicial precedent by its curtailing of rights.


In 2009, the Supreme Court allowed a girl with intellectual disabilities to continue her pregnancy after she was raped while staying at the Nari Niketan in Chandigarh. The court made the distinction under the 1971 Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act between "mental retardation" and "mental illness". The Act allows for non-consensual termination if a woman is "mentally ill", which in the post-UNCRPD world is discriminatory.


In any case, the court held that as she was "mentally retarded", and not "mentally ill", she could still exercise legal capacity regarding her reproductive choices. The Punjab and Haryana High Court had earlier held that her desire to keep the pregnancy was irrelevant as the State, as her guardian, had decided on her behalf to terminate the pregnancy.


Now, Section 106 (f) of the Bill allows for termination of pregnancy if a woman is "severely" disabled, even without her consent, as long as there is certification from a registered medical practitioner and the consent of her guardian. What is "severely" disabled is not mentioned. As statute will always trump case law, now, the reproductive choices of all women with disabilities stand threatened.

This is just one example of the inexplicable contents of the Bill, and similarly bizarre provisions can trace their roots to one source - the protectionist charity model based on medical understandings of disability that the Indian bureaucracy cannot tear itself away from.


Meanwhile, the world's understanding of disability has moved from the medical model of disability that focuses on impairments of the body and mind and therefore the need to "fix" or "normalize" them, to the social model of recognition, removal of barriers, and empowerment. In India, the position in law of persons with disabilities who were not incarcerated was largely relegated to being within the charity model, under which regular donations and grants were made available to persons with disabilities by royalty, and later, state governments. 


The drafters of this Bill might pat themselves on the back for, say, the provision of "five percent reservation in allotment of agricultural land and housing in all relevant schemes and development programmes, with appropriate priority to women with benchmark disabilities". It is doubtless beneficial - from a charity approach.

When seen from the empowerment approach, it fails. People denied legal capacity cannot execute ownership deeds. They have not been empowered to do so under the Bill. Women with disabilities face double discrimination - on account of gender and disability. They have not been empowered to overcome this under the Bill. The net effect? Very little.


The same approach has been taken with regard to employment. The government will decide what job a person with a certain disability can do and relegate those who are appointed under the reservation quota to those jobs, thus protecting them from having to do a job which may be unsuited to their disability.


Of course, there will be some jobs for which it is impossible to accommodate certain disabilities. For the others, the UNCRPD's principle of reasonable accommodation - necessary and appropriate modification and adjustments not imposing a disproportionate or undue burden, where needed in a particular case - could be used to make so many more jobs accessible to persons with disabilities, instead of ghettoizing them.


"Reasonable accommodation" has been ignored in provisions relating to employment, and has been replaced by the undefined "appropriate environment". The underlying sentiment, obviously, is that the government is doing its duty by providing some employment to some persons with disabilities who enter under these quotas, and that adjustment beyond that is unnecessary. The grant of employment therefore, is charity. The right to be able to work at a post of one's choosing and that one is qualified for - that's empowerment.


Under the Bill, the rights are to free healthcare within the vicinity for people of certain income levels, the right to priority in attendance and treatment, and the right to barrier-free healthcare infrastructure. It seems great to look at, but a comparison with the UNCRPD provisions will reveal how the rights of persons with disabilities could involve much more.


Right now, the practice of obtaining informed consent from patients before procedures is invariably sought from the guardian. Obliging medical professionals to give information regarding treatments and procedures to persons with disabilities in formats they can understand, and information that they can use to make their own decisions, is what the goal should be. Not the limiting of "accessibility" in healthcare to barrier-free environments.

Eliminating discrimination against people with disabilities when it comes to provision of health and life insurance would do more to improve their access to quality healthcare than forcing them to take treatment in the vicinity because it is subsidized. It would enable people with disabilities to make their own choices without excessive concern for financial repercussions.


The RPD Bill does not seem like something drafted by persons with disabilities themselves, which is what it was meant to be originally. It seems to have been hastily compiled by bureaucrats in the ministry who have no understanding of what these rights, crystallized in so many conferences and consultations held all over the country, mean for the persons with disabilities who were part of them. Ironically, the sequence of events is forcing the disabilities movement to turn ableist.

With time running short before the Bill is introduced, only those stakeholders who are able to readily access the internet and computers, who are able communicate in English, who are able to run to Delhi, who are able to protest on the streets, who are able to think quickly and coherently in order to draft amendments on the fly, who are able to sit for hunger strikes without damaging their health, and unlike me, are not afflicted by laryngitis and severe anxiety - are able, and are thus able to attempt to enforce changes to the Bill.


Whether these amendments, sought to be pushed through to the Cabinet, reflect the aspirations of the lakhs who were given the hope that this would be their Bill is anyone's guess - as is the question of how many of these amendments the Cabinet will actually accept. As is, in fact, the question of whether piecemeal changes can transform the Bill, since it is the very approach that is flawed, not stray phrasing. In the meanwhile, thousands of other persons with disabilities are unaware of this unexpected turn of events, and by the time the information can be made accessible to each of them, the Bill may already be passed.
 

Despite the fact that such important legislation was up for introduction, the Minister for Social Justice and Empowerment, Kumari Selja, deemed it fit to resign from her post to 'work for the Party' prior to elections, and additional charge of the Ministry has been given to the Minister for Railways, Mallikarjun Kharge.


The disinterested approach of the government is not surprising: persons with disabilities are not considered a vote bank. The Census grossly underestimates their numbers, seeing them as forming around 2 percent of the population. And in many cases, they cannot vote - the latest Delhi elections, as well as a recent RTI application filed by Dr Satender Singh, show that accessible elections are not something to look forward to this summer.


This is baffling, because having a disability is not like being a part of any other minority. As Dr Kalpana Kannabiran pointed out on January 23, 2014 at a keynote speech at the Hyderabad Central University campus, ability is temporary, it is arbitrary, and it is a matter of chance. Unlike other minority groups based on religion, caste or economic strata, the only thing keeping someone without a disability from falling under this law is the general uncertainty of life.


An accident, a hereditary condition or even excessive stress can suddenly land someone in the clutches of a law that, until yesterday, they had overlooked. And the last thing one should have to be confronted with when suddenly facing a disability is a law that creates additional ones.


Amba Salelkar is a 2006 graduate of the National Law School of India University, Bangalore, who works with the Inclusive Planet Centre for Disability Law and Policy, Chennai, founded by the late Rahul Cherian. The Centre focuses on legal analysis and advocacy on behalf of persons with disabilities.

Source : in.news.yahoo.com/no-piecemeal-change-can-fix-our-terrible-disability-bill-061219451.html