Translate

Showing posts with label The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill. Show all posts

Tuesday, 18 February 2014

Time To Enable The Disabled


Time To Enable The Disabled

A Bill as politically non-contentious as the Rights of the Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014, on which the aspirations of millions of people with disabilities are riding, is, shocking though this may sound, stuck between a rock and a hard place. On the one hand, it was recently introduced in the Rajya Sabha but disruptions over political issues like Telangana have ensured that the Bill, which seeks to increase the reservation quota for the disabled in public sector jobs and seats in higher educational institutions, was not taken up for discussion.

On the other hand, the disability rights activists seem to be divided over the proposed amendments as it is alleged that their recommendations have been ignored and it is a watered down version of their earlier demands. Moreover, it was a leaked copy of the Bill that made activists realise that the Bill to be tabled in the Rajya Sabha was not the same as the one available on the website of the ministry of social justice and empowerment, leading to protest rallies in Delhi. While the Bill, rightly, seeks to raise the number of disabilities from seven to 19, it includes only those who suffer not less than 40% of the relevant disability — this many activists feel is quite ambiguous especially in cases of intellectual disabilities and it does not ensure full legal capacity to people with disabilities.

In a country where of 70 million people with disabilities, only about 100,000 have succeeded in obtaining employment in industry, and inaccessible public infrastructure is a cause of their daily travails, this was a controversy the government could have done without had the authorities concerned kept all the stakeholders in the loop. However, practicality suggests that parliamentarians, cutting across the party lines, must now rise above politics and ensure that the Bill sees the light of day.

The Bill may be far from being perfect but given the fact that the ongoing Parliament session is the last one before the general elections, there’s no time to lose. There are several social and infrastructural barriers that need to be crossed to make the Bill effective on the ground. Instead of taking a one-step-forward-and-two-steps-back approach, the government must show urgency to build on what already exists.

Source: http://www.hindustantimes.com/comment/time-to-enable-the-disabled/article1-1184681.aspx#sthash.qtDDaNvi.dpuf

A Hurried Disabilities Bill Will Serve No Purpose


A Hurried Disabilities Bill Will Serve No Purpose



Let us not hurriedly enact a retrograde legislation for all disabilities, which would be impossible to amend for the next 25 years. In order to correct the injustice of exclusion, let us not create an equality of oppression.

The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill was introduced in the Rajya Sabha to universal criticism and till now, 16 amendments have been circulated to members of the upper House in an effort to save the Bill. The objective of the legislation was stated as "a Bill to give effect to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities" (UN CRPD). Hence it must be in consonance with the requirements of the Convention to fulfill its primary purpose. The CRPD mandates an absolute prohibition on discrimination on grounds of disability, but this Bill permits discrimination provided it is to achieve any legitimate aim, in clear violation of the CRPD!

The CRPD prohibits deprivation of liberty on grounds of disability. The Bill cleverly inserts one word to change the guarantee altogether: it says that no person shall be deprived of his or her personal liberty only on grounds of disability. This formulation was rejected while drafting the CRPD since it permits the deprivation of liberty when a person with disability is destitute or considered to be 'dangerous'. For thousands, the addition of 'only' could mean being forced to live in institutions for the rest of their lives.

The other core CRPD principle that remains to be examined is the right to exercise legal capacity on an equal basis with others in all aspects of life. Presently scores of laws disqualify persons with disabilities from marrying, inheriting, voting, etc. The CRPD seeks to offset disqualifications imposed upon people with intellectual, psychosocial and developmental disabilities by recognising their right to live their lives according to their will and preference.


However, the 2014 Bill did not even mention the right to legal capacity. In the amendment, legal capacity has been recognised as an obligation of the government, not a right of persons with disabilities. If the government fails to ensure legal capacity, then the person with disabilities can do nothing but bemoan the poor implementation of Indian laws. Consequently, entitlement of reservations in jobs becomes meaningless for persons with disabilities. If it were possible to make things worse, section 110 of the legislation states categorically that the Bill will not override any existing laws, which means all discriminatory laws will continue to be valid!


However, despite the many flaws in the Bill, people with the newly-included disabilities are pressing for its enactment because these disabilities have been waiting for inclusion in the Act since 1999 and feel they cannot wait any more. This grievance is undeniably genuine. The correct way to address this concern would be to amend the Act of 1995, whether by Act or ordinance to include the long-excluded disabilities.


Let us not hurriedly enact a retrograde legislation for all disabilities, which would be impossible to amend for the next 25 years. In order to correct the injustice of exclusion, let us not create an equality of oppression.


Source: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/hyderabad/A-hurried-disabilities-Bill-will-serve-no-purpose/articleshow/30579944.cms

Sunday, 16 February 2014

Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill Opposed


Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill Opposed

Staff Reporter
 

‘Definition of the blindness in this Bill is not clear and it will create more confusion during certification of blindness and low vision’

Activists working for rights of physically challenged have protested against efforts to pass the ‘Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014’ in current form.

Adviser of Milton Charitable Foundation for the Visually Handicapped (MCFVH) Madhaba Kumar Bisoyi, who also happens to be the assistant regional director of the IGNOU, said definition of the blindness in this Bill is not clear and it would create more confusion during certification of blindness and low vision.

He added that Section 33 (2) of this bill is also affecting the rights of physically challenged by mentioning that the employer is allowed to appoint a person without disability after one year, if the vacancy could not be filled by a person with disability, which was not allowed earlier.

President of the MCFVH Harsha Chandra Rath alleged that in the name of empowering the differently-abled through this Bill, the government was planning to curtail their rights.

He said in the existing Persons with Disability Act 1995, there is provision of age relaxation of 10 years, which has been reduced to five years in the current Bill for Group C & D jobs.

He felt this provision will affect their social as well as financial empowerment.

Academician Rajnish Kumar Arya alleged that that the current Bill violates the United Nations Charter of Rights Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD).

Being a signatory of this charter, it is India’s obligation to compile a Bill in accordance to the charter, he said. According to him, in the new Bill several issues related to rights of physically challenged had been ignored and the most important right, which is right to participation in political and public life, either diluted or ignored in this Bill, he said

Ranjan Kumar Biswal, general Secretary of the MCFVH expressed his protest against the manner in which the new Bill was drafted.

“For a Bill that was touted to be framed by an inclusive process, the version of the Bill cleared by the Cabinet was made available to the public just a fortnight before the proposed parliamentary session which seeks its introduction and passing” he said.

He added that Section 10 of the proposed Bill deals with “accessibility in voting” and mentions that the Election Commission of India and State Election Commission shall ensure that all polling stations are accessible to persons with disabilities and that all materials related to the electoral process are easily understandable by and accessible to them. “This is seriously limiting the scope of Article 29 of UNCRPD, which recognises the right and opportunity to stand for elections”, Mr Biswal said.

Source: http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-otherstates/rights-of-persons-with-disabilities-bill-opposed/article5683618.ece


Monday, 10 February 2014

Disabilities Rights Bill Retrograde: Activists


Disabilities Rights Bill Retrograde: Activists



 “It doesn’t adopt UN convention in its true spirit”


The Rights of the Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014, tabled in the Rajya Sabha, has evoked sharp reactions from disabilities rights activists across the country.

The Hindu, in a report, “New Bill to strengthen definition of disabilities,” on February 9, has said that under pressure from disability rights activists, the government is likely to introduce 16 amendments in the Bill on Monday.

The government had tabled, in a hurry, an older version of the Bill in the Rajya Sabha as the amendments approved by the Cabinet late on Thursday could not be incorporated in the draft.

The Chennai-based Disability Rights Alliance (DRA), a conglomerate of disability rights activists, says the Bill is “regressive and retrograde,” and does not adopt the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disability (UNCRPD) in its true spirit.

In a statement here on Sunday, the DRA and several other organisations said Section 110 of the Bill provided that its provisions shall be in addition to, and not in derogation of, the provisions of any other law in force, which effectively meant that all laws which actively discriminated against persons with disabilities remained untouched. This violated the State’s obligation under the U.N. convention to take all appropriate measures, including legislation, to modify or abolish laws, regulations, customs and practices that constituted such discrimination.


“According to the UNCRPD, state parties are to grant an unconditional right to equality and non-discrimination to all persons with disabilities, on a par with others. In this Bill, the Right of Equality is curtailed under Section 3(3), which says the right against discrimination exists ‘unless it can be shown that the impugned act or omission is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.” 


The terms “proportionate means” and “legitimate aim,” it said, are highly subjective and can perpetuate discrimination.


Further, the statement said, the UNCRPD lays down specific obligations of the State while discussing multiple discrimination faced by women with disabilities. States are obliged to take measures to ensure that they enjoy fully and equally all human rights and fundamental freedoms.


However, the Bill fails to acknowledge these beyond a cursory “hat tip” in Section 3(2), which says the appropriate government shall take special measures to protect the rights of women and children with disability and also take steps to utilise the capacity of persons with disabilities by providing an appropriate environment. This is limited to “protection” of rights and not empowerment.


Importantly, the DRA sought political representation for differently-abled people to ensure that their voices were heard.


“There are some local laws and executive orders that disallow persons with disabilities from contesting elections,” Rajiv, a legal expert with DRA said.

Source: http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/disabilities-rights-bill-retrograde-activists/article5671384.ece